For the base material, I used chalkboard fabric. It cut perfectly and easily using the deep cut blade and custom setting for faux leather. The pom poms for the bats were 1 1/2" and for the spider I used 1". Once cut, I painted each with black glitter glue. I used 1" small oval alligator clips to attach the bats and spiders to using hot glue.
Last, I cut and edged my tags and added the clips for gift giving.
Here is my Design Space file to recreate: